Please, accept cookies in order to load the content.

Bot Club investigates the possibilities of Garri Kasparov's Centaur model as a metaphor for healthy working relations between humans and artificial intelleigences. Human-AI relations are complicated and often downright disfunctional. They are understood through many incompatible mythologies, each formed around their own concerns and backed by their own facts. At this Bot Club the aim is to bring the myths, technologies and politics of human-AI relations closer to each other - from a position of mutual respect, yet aware of each other's shortcomings. 

date
26/03/2020
time
19:30 – 21:00
language
English
also this evening

18:00-19:30 Thursday Bite 

The museum is free of charge from 17:00-21:00 

location

Het Nieuwe Instituut
Museumpark 25
3015 CB Rotterdam

entrance

Standard€ 7,50
Students, CJP, Friends and Members of Het Nieuwe Instituut€ 3,75

There are reasonable but also superstitious fears for human obsolence in certain domains of society. There are justified and wildly erratic hopes for the precise observations that AIs can make. AIs can’t be trusted: they amplify human biases and mistakes that are present in the data sets that are used for their training.  AIs can be relied upon. They can be trained to be inhumanly good at precise cognitive tasks like winning a game of go, or recognising early signs of tumours on x-rays.  AIs can be brilliant artists, but sadly cannot have have artistic experiences.  AIs are alien minds that should be able to see in ways, unhampered by human-centric categorisations. AIs are also unbelievably stupid. They can’t tell the difference between a truck and a piece of sky, they see snow mobiles in snowy landscapes with only trees and rocks, and regularly mistake a cat for a human. 

Recommender systems

A promising early proposal for a kind of normalised human-AI relation came from chess champion Garry Kasparov after he lost the game against the AI Deep Blue in 1997- the first time a machine intelligence publicly beat a human intelligence in a field considered a high mark of human capacity. 

Following his defeat, Kasparov discovered that a human chess grandmaster supported by an AI always beats an AI or a human on their own and he developed ‘centaur chess’. This is always played between two teams, each consisting of a human player and an AI assistant.  

Basically, the AI here works as a recommender system just like in Spotify, Netflix or Amazon. The centaur is a metaphor for a human-AI relationship, with the AI doing the legwork of working out all the possible moves and preselecting potentially useful ones, and the human as the brain making the ultimate decisions. 

Could this be a model for functional human-AI relations? What would be needed for humans and AIs be able to trust each other in such relationships?  And is the centaur the best metaphor for this?

Bot Club 

Bot Club  is a recurring programme on algorithmic culture, one of the long-term research projects by Het Nieuwe Instituut’s Research & Development department.

Thursday Bite

Before the Thursday Night you can grab a bite to eat with the speakers and staff of Het Nieuwe Instituut. At 18:00 Het Nieuwe Café will serve a light vegetarian meal. Dinner vouchers are available for € 7.70 up to a day before the particular Thursday Night event via the Tickets link. 

Become a Member

Become a Member of Het Nieuwe Instituut and you’ll support our mission to navigate the vast and evolving field of design. You’ll also be inspired by our special program of Members’ events, meeting up with other like-minded people as we invite you to reflect with us on design’s changing role in technology, economics, culture and society.

Thursday Night at Het Nieuwe Instituut
Luca Napoli

Thursday Night Live! is a weekly programme of lectures, screenings and discussions on architecture, design and digital culture. Developments and critical insights are discussed by thinkers, designers and makers from the Netherlands and abroad.